On this page
- What a client carries from one session to the next
- A week the therapist never sees
- Some of the week should stay the client's
- What Citt does with the week
- Frequently Asked Questions
- What gets lost between therapy sessions?
- Does practice between sessions affect therapy outcomes?
- Can a therapist read what a client writes to Citt between sessions?
- Does Citt improve therapy outcomes?
When I was in therapy for depression, I meditated, kept a journal and used some early AI tools between sessions. I kept wondering what would change if my therapist could see the useful parts of that work. Citt came out of that question, and underneath it is a simpler one: how much of a client's week ever reaches the session.
What a client carries from one session to the next
Probably less than either the client or the therapist assumes. Jason Lee and Allison Harvey studied 30 adults with bipolar disorder and insomnia who were in weekly therapy. At the start of each session, clients listed every point they could remember from the previous one, and the researchers compared those lists with the therapists' records. Clients recalled between 19.6% and 36.9% of the points.1 Those who recalled more did better on some of the sleep and quality-of-life measures. It is one small study in one population, and the authors concluded that memory for therapy is poor.
Then there is the work a session sets up for the days after it. In cognitive and behavioral therapies, practice between sessions is part of the treatment. A 2010 meta-analysis of 46 studies by Nikolaos Kazantzis and colleagues found a pooled effect of d = 0.48 in favor of therapy with homework over the same therapy without it.2 A second meta-analysis, of 23 studies and 2,183 clients, found that clients who completed more of their homework had better outcomes (r = 0.26).3 Both cover CBT-family treatments, so they say little about psychodynamic or humanistic work, where the week matters in other ways.
So the week is where much of the change is meant to happen, and the session is where the therapist learns about the week. What reaches the session is the client's recollection on the day, shaped by their mood and by what feels safe to say.
A week the therapist never sees
Picture a client working on panic attacks. Her therapist has given her an exercise to try when panic starts in a supermarket queue. She tries it three times that week. On Monday she gets through it. On Wednesday she leaves after a few seconds. On Saturday she asks her partner to do the shopping.
In the next session she says the week was "not great." That is accurate, and it loses Monday, which her therapist would want to hear about. If she had written a few lines after each attempt, or talked them through with support her therapist had set up, the session could start from Monday and move to what was different on Wednesday.
The same thing happens over months. A goal agreed in the third session can drop out of conversation for six weeks without anyone deciding to let it go. A depression score can rise slowly enough that each session feels much like the last. For the client's side of this, see the guide to AI support between sessions.
Some of the week should stay the client's
The gap may also do work of its own. What a client chooses to bring to a session is part of the therapy, and a therapist who can read everything changes that choice. Some clients might write less honestly if they expected to be read, and others might feel watched. And a therapist with a full caseload cannot read a week of messages from every client.
These points set the terms for doing this well. A client should know what their therapist can see before they write anything. The support between sessions should help the client do the practice and decide what to bring back, so that the important conversation still happens in the room. The therapist should be able to look when it helps, with no expectation that they read everything.
This is also where between-session support can go wrong in the other direction, by becoming the relationship. I have written about that risk separately, in why attachment matters in mental health AI.
What Citt does with the week
In Citt, the therapist sets up the AI support for each client and chooses its approach, such as CBT or DBT skills, or writes their own instructions. The AI's instructions steer it away from heavy reassurance and toward bringing recurring themes back to the therapist. The therapist can read a client's conversations with the AI when they choose. Assessments such as the PHQ-9 and GAD-7 go out when a client starts, Citt tells the therapist when a follow-up is due, and the therapist sees the change from baseline. The features page lists the rest.
There is no evidence yet that this improves outcomes. What it changes is how much of the week is within the therapist's reach when the session starts. A therapist who knows about Monday can spend the hour on what was different that day, and a therapist who sees that a goal has gone quiet can ask about it while the client still remembers setting it.
Footnotes
-
Lee, J. Y., & Harvey, A. G. (2015). Memory for therapy in bipolar disorder and comorbid insomnia. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 83(1), 92-102. Thirty adults in a trial of two therapies for insomnia; a small sample in one population. ↩
-
Kazantzis, N., Whittington, C., & Dattilio, F. (2010). Meta-analysis of homework effects in cognitive and behavioral therapy: A replication and extension. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice, 17, 144-156. Forty-six studies (N = 1,072); d = 0.48 when restricted to controlled studies comparing the same therapy with and without homework. ↩
-
Mausbach, B. T., Moore, R., Roesch, S., Cardenas, V., & Patterson, T. L. (2010). The relationship between homework compliance and therapy outcomes: An updated meta-analysis. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 34(5), 429-438. Twenty-three studies (2,183 participants); a correlation, so it does not show that homework causes the better outcomes. ↩
Frequently Asked Questions
What gets lost between therapy sessions?
Much of what was discussed. In one study of 30 adults in weekly therapy, clients recalled between about a fifth and a third of the points from their previous session.
Does practice between sessions affect therapy outcomes?
In cognitive and behavioral therapies it does on average. Meta-analyses published in 2010 found better outcomes when therapy included homework and when clients completed more of it. Both covered cognitive and behavioral therapies only.
Can a therapist read what a client writes to Citt between sessions?
Yes. The therapist can read a client's conversations with the AI support when they choose. They are not expected to read every message or to watch conversations as they happen.
Does Citt improve therapy outcomes?
There is no evidence yet that it does. Citt puts more of the client's week within the therapist's reach, and whether that leads to better outcomes has not been tested.
Stop rewriting notes from scratch
Citt.ai drafts session notes under your review, keeps between-session context in one place, and stays therapist-led. Start free. No card required.
Related Articles
- What the Trials of AI Mental Health Chatbots Show, and What They Leave Open
The published trials of AI mental health chatbots, including Therabot, Limbic Care and Ash: what each compared, what it found and what is still open.
- What Citt.ai Shows a Therapist, and What You Have to Take on Trust
What a therapist can see and change in Citt.ai, from client conversations to crisis alerts and draft notes, and the three things that cannot be checked.
- How Citt.ai Screens Client Messages for Risk, and Where It Stops
What happens when a client writes something alarming to AI support between sessions: how Citt.ai screens messages, who is alerted, and what it misses.
- Therapy 1.0, 2.0 and 3.0: Where AI Between Sessions Fits
Therapy 1.0, 2.0 and 3.0: how therapy delivery has changed, where AI support between sessions fits, and what the research has tested so far.