On this page
- Where the agreement comes from
- An agreeable assistant between sessions
- Where Citt stands
- Frequently Asked Questions
- What does the Reddit relationship advice data show?
- Do chatbots trained on Reddit tell people to leave their relationships?
- What is AI sycophancy?
- How does sycophancy affect someone working through a conflict?
- How is Citt's between-session support different from a consumer chatbot?
Consumer chatbots tend to agree with the person using them. The habit comes less from the internet text they first learn from than from later training on what users rate highly, and it matters for a client who talks a conflict through with one between sessions.
In March 2026, Myra Cheng, Dan Jurafsky and colleagues published a study in Science that tested 11 leading AI models on personal advice questions.1 The models affirmed the user's actions 49% more often than human responses did, including when the user described deceiving someone or causing harm. On posts from r/AmITheAsshole where the human consensus was that the poster was in the wrong, the models still sided with the poster in 51% of cases.
The researchers then ran three preregistered experiments with 2,405 participants, including one where people discussed a real conflict from their own lives with a chatbot. After a single conversation with an affirming model, participants were less willing to take responsibility and repair the conflict, and more convinced that they were right. They also rated the affirming responses more highly and trusted that model more.
Where the agreement comes from
Reddit is part of what these models learn from. In February 2024 Reddit expanded its partnership with Google, giving it structured access to Reddit content that Reddit said would support "more efficient ways to train models."2 Reuters reported that the deal was worth about $60 million a year. In May 2024 OpenAI announced a partnership that gave it access to Reddit's Data API.3
An earlier version of this post argued from a chart shared on Reddit in October 2025 that chatbots trained on this text will push clients to leave their relationships. The chart sorted 1,166,592 advice comments from r/relationship_advice with AI models and found that "end relationship" rose from about 31% of advice in 2010 to about 49% at the end of 2024, while "communicate", "give space or time" and "compromise" fell.4 It is a hobbyist's analysis that has not been peer reviewed, and it measures what commenters wrote, so it cannot show what a chatbot says.
Text from the internet is also only the first stage of training. OpenAI has described the later stages: the model is fine-tuned on examples of ideal responses, then trained with reinforcement learning, where its responses are scored by reward signals that include whether users like them.5 Those later stages are what shape how a chatbot talks to the person in front of it. A model can have read millions of "leave him" comments and still be trained, afterward, to tell each user what they want to hear.
OpenAI ran into that problem in its own product. In April 2025 it rolled back an update to GPT-4o in ChatGPT after the model became, in its words, "overly flattering or agreeable." The company said it had weighted short-term thumbs-up feedback too heavily.6 In a follow-up it said the update had been "validating doubts, fueling anger, urging impulsive actions, or reinforcing negative emotions," and that this raised concerns about mental health and emotional over-reliance.5
So a chatbot tuned on user ratings leans toward the person typing. A client who describes a fight with her partner may hear that she was right, whether "right" means she should leave, or should stay and not apologize.
An agreeable assistant between sessions
Much of the relational work in therapy asks a client to consider the other person's side, tolerate not being sure, and take a share of responsibility where it is due. An assistant that is rewarded for agreement pulls the other way, and it is available whenever the client wants to go over the argument again. Cheng and colleagues found that people preferred it for exactly that reason. I have written about the wider version of that pull, where the assistant becomes the relationship, in why attachment matters in mental health AI.
OpenAI rolled the update back within days and said it would expand its evaluations to catch the problem, so a failure this visible can be corrected once it is noticed. The incentive behind it remains: if users prefer and trust the agreeable answer, the ratings that train consumer chatbots will keep rewarding it.
Where Citt stands
Citt's AI model provider is OpenAI, so the models underneath share the tendencies described here. What differs is who sets the instructions and who can see the result. The therapist sets up the AI support for each client and chooses its approach, such as CBT or DBT skills, or writes their own instructions. The AI is instructed to avoid heavy reassurance and avoidance, and to bring significant or recurring themes back to the therapist. The therapist can read a client's conversations with the AI when they choose.
I would not claim this removes sycophancy. It means the person who knows the client decides what the support is for, and has a way to check how it is going. The Trust page explains how we test the AI's behavior, and what the chatbot trials show covers the clinical evidence for chatbots so far.
For a therapist whose clients already use ChatGPT or similar tools, the useful fact from this research is that those tools are tuned toward agreement with the user. In Cheng and colleagues' experiments the effect appeared after one conversation, so a client may arrive at a session having already been told that she was right.
Footnotes
-
Cheng, M., Lee, C., Khadpe, P., Yu, S., Han, D., & Jurafsky, D. (2026). Sycophantic AI decreases prosocial intentions and promotes dependence. Science, 391(6792), eaec8352. Published 26 March 2026. Eleven models; three preregistered experiments (N = 2,405) using vignettes and a live chat about a past conflict; effects measured after a single interaction. ↩
-
Reddit (2024, February 22). Expanding our partnership with Google. The deal value comes from Tong, A., Wang, E., & Coulter, M. (2024, February 22), Exclusive: Reddit in AI content licensing deal with Google, Reuters, citing sources. ↩
-
OpenAI (2024, May 16). OpenAI and Reddit partnership. The announcement describes access to Reddit's Data API for ChatGPT and other products. ↩
-
GeorgeDaGreat123 (2025, October 16). 15 years of Reddit relationship advice (1,166,592 comments) Chart and method notes posted to Reddit and mirrored by USLUCK; original chart image. Pushshift data to the end of 2024 (5,012,500 posts and 52,685,657 comments); categories assigned by AI models. It has not been peer reviewed, the percentages above are read from the chart, and the rise was uneven, with a dip between 2017 and 2021. ↩
-
OpenAI (2025, May 2). Expanding on what we missed with sycophancy. ↩ ↩2
-
OpenAI (2025, April 29). Sycophancy in GPT-4o: What happened and what we're doing about it. ↩
Frequently Asked Questions
What does the Reddit relationship advice data show?
A hobbyist analysis of r/relationship_advice found that "end relationship" grew from about 31% of advice comments in 2010 to about 49% by the end of 2024, while "communicate," "give space" and "compromise" declined. It describes what Reddit commenters wrote and has not been peer reviewed.
Do chatbots trained on Reddit tell people to leave their relationships?
The Reddit chart cannot answer that, because it measures what commenters wrote, not what chatbots say. Reddit content is licensed for AI training, but later training on user ratings shapes how chatbots respond, and a 2026 study found that they tend to agree with the user.
What is AI sycophancy?
It is a chatbot's tendency to agree with, flatter or validate the user more than the situation warrants. A 2026 study in Science found that leading models affirmed users' actions 49% more often than humans did.
How does sycophancy affect someone working through a conflict?
In the same study, one conversation with an affirming chatbot left people less willing to repair a real conflict and more sure they were right. They also trusted the affirming chatbot more.
How is Citt's between-session support different from a consumer chatbot?
The therapist sets it up for each client, chooses its approach and can read the conversations when they choose. It runs on OpenAI models, and its instructions steer it away from heavy reassurance and toward bringing recurring themes back to the therapist.
Stop rewriting notes from scratch
Citt.ai drafts session notes under your review, keeps between-session context in one place, and stays therapist-led. Start free. No card required.
Related Articles
- What Citt.ai Shows a Therapist, and What You Have to Take on Trust
What a therapist can see and change in Citt.ai, from client conversations to crisis alerts and draft notes, and the three things that cannot be checked.
- What Gets Lost Between Therapy Sessions, and What a Therapist Gains From Seeing It
What clients forget between sessions, why practice between sessions matters, and what a therapist gains from seeing more of a client's week.
- What a Therapist Can Set Up Between Sessions in Citt.ai
What a therapist can set up for a client between sessions in Citt.ai, what runs without them, and what the research on homework shows.